8 Comments

Yes, and the good priest of Newmarket also said "we feed the fear by silence." That is very true; and yet even with the noise of the lawful hue and cry, the media fed us with still more fear - by being silent on the good, the peace, and the convivium of the innumerable protesters and supporters. And on all this the bishops were almost silent - except for the Quebec bishops writing a tortuous defence of their complicity .. as if it was in the interest of a greater good.

Expand full comment

A priest friend expressed concerns for fast-escalating persecution in Canada. I replied that we can largely thank our bishops for that: "As Trudoskyites crush the freedom convoy they will see all its 'remnants' as needing worse than vilification, and that includes anyone who was organizing prayer gatherings, or even those attending if they can be identified.

Most sad of all will be the record of complicity in parts of the Church. Some churches closed their doors on the protesters who might have benefitted from historic sanctuary, believing as pastors did that violent threats including bombs were any more credible than the Ptomkin show of guns conveniently 'found' by police with no evidence of them searching for them.

In total subservience to the state, all the bishops in Quebec (including the primate of Canada) and a number outside Quebec had excommunicated the unvaxxed or the un-passported before the freedom convoy arrived, and are still holding the harsh line as their territories relax passport mandates at shops, ski loppets and medical clinics.

What was a 'quiet revolution' is now a revolution of very loud silence. These bishops will be unable to recover moral authority, making the Church no haven in Quebec or many other places for those of conscience. Indeed they have thrown conscience itself under the bus."

Expand full comment

Thank-you Douglas.

Let us Canadians, religious and secular alike, remember the words of the late Leonard Cohen in these foreboding times:

God is alive, magic is afoot

God is alive, magic is afoot

God is afoot, magic is alive

Alive is afoot, magic never died

God never sickened

Many poor men lied

Many sick men lied

Magic never weakened

Magic never hid

Magic always ruled

God is afoot, God never died

God was ruler

Though his funeral lengthened

Though his mourners thickened

Magic never fled

Though his shrouds were hoisted

The naked God did live

Though his words were twisted

The naked magic thrived

Though his death was published

Round and round the world

The heart did not believe

Many hurt men wondered

Many struck men bled

Magic never faltered

Magic always lead

Many stones were rolled

But God would not lie down

Many wild men lied

Many fat men listened

Though they offered stones

Magic still was fed

Though they locked their coffers

God was always served

Magic is afoot, God is alive

Alive is afoot

Alive is in command

Many weak men hungered

Many strong men thrived

Though they boast of solitude

God was at their side

Nor the dreamer in his cell

Nor the captain on the hill

Magic is alive

Though his death was pardoned

Round and round the world

The heart would not believe

Though laws were carved in marble

They could not shelter men

Though altars built in parliaments

They could not order men

Police arrested magic and magic went with them

Mmmmm.... For magic loves the hungry

But magic would not tarry

It moves from arm to arm

It would not stay with them

Magic is afoot

It cannot come to harm

It rests in an empty palm

It spawns in an empty mind

But magic is no instrument

Magic is the end

Many men drove magic

But magic stayed behind

Many strong men lied

They only passed through magic

And out the other side

Many weak men lied

They came to God in secret

And though they left Him nourished

They would not tell who healed

Though mountains danced before them

They said that God was dead

Though his shrouds were hoisted

The naked God did live

This I mean to whisper to my mind

This I mean to laugh within my mind

This I mean my mind to serve

Til' service is but magic

Moving through the world

And mind itself is magic

Coursing through the flesh

And flesh itself is magic

Dancing on a clock

And time itself

The magic length of God

Leonard Cohen~Beautiful Losers

Expand full comment

Your letter to the bishops, here addressed to one bishop of Quebec, makes the main points excellently well. It does fail to add that what is in the balance is the freedom of conscience from coercion, which the Church above all else must defend. You may be interested in a letter to similar effect that I sent to the archbishop of Gatineau. I'll forward it to you if you wish (you have my email address).

Expand full comment

This is a great essay. Thank you. I attended both the Ottawa and Toronto protests on Jan. 29 and Feb. 5 respectively and have supported the group. I pray for their success.

Expand full comment

Douglas Farrow reads the situation entirely correctly. He stands fully on the teaching of Scripture and on the teaching of the whole Church through the ages that has been faithful to Scripture. The last two years have seen a coup in which governments and the worldly powers have exceeded their mandate to do us good and have started to rage out of control. Once we concede that their lawlessness is somehow legitimate, there is no natural stopping place, and these powers will really dismantle the rule of law and erect a cult in which they are the god they want us to worship. They know only power. We cannot acknowledge the validity of their power-without-authority and so cannot give them the obedience they demand. We can only recognise the authority and power of God, and tell them about the judgment of God on those who do evil.

What comes next certainly demands courage patience and suffering, but in baptism we took up the cross, and now must bear it very publicly for the sake of our society. We must remind our society that all its liberties and rule of law come from the gospel, not only once historically but now and every day. I have admired Douglas Farrow for a long time. At this moment he is doing exactly what every Christian and citizen must do, for Canada and wider. I thank God for him.

Expand full comment

DHK: Thanks for these words. Did we imagine we would see such things in our time? Yet many still cling to the notion that it is mere imagination.

Expand full comment